"Silence" 2 posts Sort by created date Sort by defined ordering View as a grid View as a list

Fences, Weapons, Gifts: Silences in the Context of Addiction

From the abstract:

Through the years, many have struggled to understand silence as a phenomenon and as a communicative tool, and the result of this struggle is a multi-disciplinary body of literature full of more contradiction than agreement about the definitions, values, and uses of silence (Acheson, 2007). In much of this work (e.g. Anzaldúa,1987; Foss and Foss, 1991; hooks, 1989; Lakoff, 1990; Olsen, 1978), silence is juxtaposed against speech in a binary of power, with silences and the silenced perceived as less powerful while the spoken and those who speak are deemed more powerful. However, continued scholarly disagreements over silence make it clear that the relationship between silence and speech, as well as the relationship between each of these and power, cannot be explained by a simple binary, and that one’s perception of these relationships is often dependent upon one’s paradigmatic perspective (Acheson, 2007).

Acheson, K. (2013). Fences, Weapons, Gifts: Silences in the Context of Addiction. In: S. Malhotra, & A. C. Rowe (Eds.). Silence, Feminism, Power. Palgrave Macmillan.

0 comments 0 reposts

Profile picture of Purdue CILMAR

Purdue CILMAR onto Silence

Silence as Gesture: Rethinking the Nature of Communicative Silences

From the abstract:

Silence and speech are often defined in relation to each other. In much scholarship, the two are perceived as polar opposites; speech enjoys primacy in this dichotomy, with silence negatively perceived as a lack of speech. As a consequence of this binary thinking, scholars remain unable to study the full range of the meanings and uses of silence in human interactions or even to fully recognize its communicative power. Merleau-Ponty described language as a gesture, made possible by the fact that we are bodies in a physical world. Language does not envelop or clothe thought; ideas materialize as embodied language, whether spoken or written. If silence is, as I argue here, as like speech as it is different, perhaps silence, too, can be a gesture. Rather than simply a background for expressed thought, if we considered silence to be embodied, to be a mating of the phenomenal and existential bodies, how might that affect current misconceptions of silence and subsequent limitations on the study of communicative silences?

Kris Acheson, Silence as Gesture: Rethinking the Nature of Communicative Silences, Communication Theory, Volume 18, Issue 4, November 2008, Pages 535–555, https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1468-2885.2008.00333.x

0 comments 0 reposts

Profile picture of Purdue CILMAR

Purdue CILMAR onto Silence